June 2, 2009

Recommendation Politics


This is fresh, heard one hour ago: at the Bhaktivedanta Manor, near London, one initiation ceremony was held today, 2 June 2009. One of the initiates, a lady, had a recommendation from a devotee authorized to issue recommendations. She showed up, submitted the recommendation, fulfilled other requirements, and took initiation. You may tend to comment: “Haribol!” but no celebratory Haribols were heard from a temple president in another city who claims some “jurisdiction” over this person and who objects to the procedure, to the point—I hear—of saying that the initiation should be cancelled, rendered null and void. Another temple president, from yet another English city, is branding this reaction as “politics”… It seems that a holy ceremony for spiritual emancipation risks being tinged by power-politics and fuel some unholy game.


It’s with sadness and concern that I am writing this entry. I have been witnessing the sacred function of recommending a candidate for initiation debasing, in some cases, to a less-sacred social and psychological function of control and territorial jurisdiction.


I have seen a growing tendency of local yatras—on the city, nation and even continental level—imposing more and more demands on the candidates for initiation, a plethora of heavier prerequisites, even in direct contradiction and infringement of existing ISKCON laws.


Perhaps even more disturbingly, such edicts have often no foundation in sastric injunction or traditional Gaudiya Vaisnava practice (in other words, are products of mental speculation).


A couple of examples? In Kuala Lumpur Malaysia, the local temple arbitrarily decided that:


1. Candidates for initiation must accept a counselor if they ever want to be initiated.

2. All the members of the counselors’ council (ten people), must agree that the person is ready for initiation; even one objector has the power to veto the initiation.


ISKCON UK took the radical (and apparently illegitimate) step of doubling the preparation time for initiation: From six months (ISKCON law) of practice (sixteen rounds and four regs) before being able to request the pranama mantra from the guru of one’s choice to one year. After that, from six months (ISKCON law) waiting period before the initiation, to one year. So, from a total of a minimum one year of chanting sixteen rounds and following the four regulative principles, to a minimum of two years.


Not only that; they also demand financial contributions from the candidates, in open disregard of ISKCON law that clearly says:

15.4.1 - Initiation of Congregational Devotees . . . It shall be prohibited to require a minimum donation or financial commitment or other requirements not mentioned by Srila Prabhupada or ISKCON Law.”


I could go on with examples of such anomalies, these “requirements not mentioned by Srila Prabhupada or ISKCON Law,” but you get the idea.


This situation raises a few questions, which I consider important for the understanding and the future of the mission. For instance, who in ISKCON has the legitimate authority to establish standards for initiation and corresponding requisites for recommendation? My answer: The Governing Body Commission and no one else. Letting each smaller or larger ISKCON enclave establish its own norms is tantamount of declaring those branches and areas beyond GBC control in this most sacred and crucial field of initiating new devotees.


Unfortunately conditioned human (and animal) tendency is to attempt to dominate and control other living entities (tendency known in Sanskrit as “isvara bhava”); Temple Presidents and other officers who aren’t yet completely free from this tendency might rationalize “dovetailing” it in Krishna consciousness by establishing more stringent rules than the elaborate guidelines already existing in ISKCON law. I am not doubting that some of them might have genuine concern for the preparation of the candidates or sincere interest in seeing the process applied as purely and carefully as possible; at the same time the “isvara bhava” might creep in the form of:


1. Unauthorizedly forcing upon candidates new strictures and burdens.

2. Demanding some form of emotional, financial, social and/or service allegiance to one’s own project.

3. Enjoying the subtle (or gross) power of determining if the initiation will take place or not, while keeping the candidates on their toes and exerting some submission-inducing pressure.

4. Having the satisfaction of blockading or immobilizing the process of formal development of the relation between guru and disciple (perhaps unconsciously thinking: “I might not be on the level of giving initiation, but at least I can stop it from being given!”)


What could be the solution to this often painful social and spiritual stalemate?


While we should work to re-establish ISKCON law where it has been locally overturned and disregarded, I am proposing we take a good look at the possibility of deregulating the whole process by empowering other devotees to provide the recommendation.

What do you think about having three brahmanas signing the recommendation? Three devotees—in “good standing”—who have second initiation, who know the candidate well enough to be able to say: “To the best of my understanding I trust this person’s assurance that s/he is chanting sixteen rounds daily and following the four regulative principles.”


Why the temple should be bothered or burdened with the responsibility of being the only authorized outlet for recommending people? Any sastric evidence for such an idea, that the spiritual life of people should be somewhat negotiated only and exclusively through the administrative structures of the places of worship? In Vaisnavism we don’t have a demarcation between clergy and laity: second initiation and the privilege to directly serve the Deities are open to every member of the extended community. Why not empowering those who have come to the stage of being second initiated devotees with the opportunity to recommend candidates for initiation? Why a brahmana living outside the temple should be considered less reliable than every temple officer?


This simplification may well result in less headaches for the temples (who often don’t know the candidates very well); less opportunity for ego-centric controlling sprees; less psychological burdens and tensions for the candidates (who often feel forced to play the political game to be able to get recommended); less artificial strictures on the holy interaction between guru and disciple; less (apparently adharmic) domination by younger devotees who restrict more senior devotees (gurus) in their services to the movement.


I look forward to hear from you about the cases of local yatras inventing stricter rules than those already existing in ISKCON law and on your opinions on these delicate matters.

29 comments:

Rob said...

I work within the UK yatra and have first hand experience of such shennanigans. My own initiation was blocked by a person I had never even spoke with. The grounds were that the person who recommended me, a well-known brahmana of 25 years good standing, had not been formally "approved" by the GBC to make recommendations.

I have also watched mortified as more and more administrative obstacles are placed in the path of other prospective initiation candidates at a particular temple.

The reason given is the raising of standards. However, I happen to know that individuals involved in the creation of this system are frequently critical of gurus relationships with their disciples, particularly over instructions that go contrary to the desires of local administrators.

It appears such individuals are paranoid in two ways. Firstly, in not allowing prospective disciples to develop direct relationships with their gurus. And secondly, in not allowing gurus to freely instruct their disciples.

It cannot be the role of persons in administrative posts, however senior, to come between guru and disciple. Such intervention can lead to serious damage to the disciples faith in both the process and the institution.

I very much agree with your suggestion that all initiated brahmanas should be permitted to make recommendation for initiation, and that rules and standards for recommendation be uniform globally, and in accordance with Srila Prabhupada's original instructions.

Thank you for giving the opportunity of discussing this crucial issue.

Your servant,
Rob

Anonymous said...

Please reply to the flurry of comments in namahatta.org


Please verify with Kaunteya prabhu if indeed he got the info about KL from a tyrant in KL or was it from the TP himself when Kaunteya pr made his visit to KL earlier?

Let's put an end to speculation from people in the KL management...

Anonymous said...

windows 7 registry cleaner , A computer program software that scans the Your computer windows registry and appears for dated and ill records.
Programs frequently generate Registry entries for temporary data and pointers along with other files, but never remove them. Additionally, http://www.registry1000.com/2010/05/09/windows-7-registry-cleaner/ , [url=windows 7 registry cleaner]http://www.registry1000.com/2010/05/09/windows-7-registry-cleaner/[/url] if folders are manually deleted by the user.
Registry entries may point to files that do not exist. A Registry cleaner can ahtvniwxnjnjnjnnjaw participate a bundle of method tools or even a stand-alone, windows 7 registry cleaner package

Anonymous said...

Our company creates a subject card on the underpinning of harmonious ' and pretty projects.
These projects are carried in default close the cards the most outstanding pike of unambiguous artists and designers in
the market who are experts in every intelligibility of the word. They are also very extensible, so you can
complete jolly interesting trade card designs, depending on the individual needs of each client.
We do not own a mistress printing machines undertake the highest blue blood of each own card.
Deviating batch of dossier allows you to upon the expectations of parallel with the most urgent customers
from every conceivable industry. We certify the print and amenities of portly quantities of vocation
cards in the shortest conceivable time. In our pack, the highest quality is the payment of the proposed
value and honest amenities from people receiving and carrying out an decree in place of obligation cards.
With access to the services offered including our website, you can with dispatch and without undue
formalities place an degree object of goods, over again the outline and approved it and ordered some job
cards. Choose our company as a sympathetic subject membership card is oft a oath for success.
Greet
Merio [url=http://www.kalendarze.dogory.pl]Kalendarze[/url]

Anonymous said...

hi, does anyone have a great blog as a replacement for [url=http://neopets-cheats.us]Neopets Cheats[/url]?

Anonymous said...

Buy Neopoints to archive your highest target on Neopets.
Neopets is a very hard plan to collect Neopoints yourself in, it may experience months of hardwork moral to institute 1,000,000 Neopoints!
[url=http://buyneopoints.org]Buy Neopoints[/url] and clear the essential Neopets cheats!

Neopets has tons of games you can contend in, and when you come by neopoints, it will up your savoir faire much bettert!
Take a shot us absent from today and you won't mourn it, Neopoints packages start from well-grounded $2.25!
Buy Neopoints

Anonymous said...

Thank you, that was extremely valuable and interesting...I will be back again to read more on this topic.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing this link, but unfortunately it seems to be offline... Does anybody have a mirror or another source? Please answer to my post if you do!

I would appreciate if a staff member here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com could post it.

Thanks,
James

Anonymous said...

Top website, I had not come across iskconoclast.blogspot.com before in my searches!
Keep up the wonderful work!

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing this link, but unfortunately it seems to be down... Does anybody have a mirror or another source? Please reply to my post if you do!

I would appreciate if a staff member here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com could post it.

Thanks,
Jules

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing this link, but unfortunately it seems to be down... Does anybody have a mirror or another source? Please reply to my post if you do!

I would appreciate if a staff member here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com could post it.

Thanks,
Oliver

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing the link, but unfortunately it seems to be offline... Does anybody have a mirror or another source? Please answer to my post if you do!

I would appreciate if a staff member here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com could post it.

Thanks,
Jack

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing the link, but unfortunately it seems to be offline... Does anybody have a mirror or another source? Please answer to my post if you do!

I would appreciate if a staff member here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com could post it.

Thanks,
John

Anonymous said...

Hi there,

This is a question for the webmaster/admin here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com.

Can I use some of the information from this blog post right above if I provide a backlink back to your site?

Thanks,
Peter

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing the link, but unfortunately it seems to be offline... Does anybody have a mirror or another source? Please reply to my message if you do!

I would appreciate if a staff member here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com could post it.

Thanks,
John

Anonymous said...

Have you considered the fact that this might work another way? I am wondering if anyone else has come across something
like this in the past? Let me know your thoughts...

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing the link, but argg it seems to be offline... Does anybody have a mirror or another source? Please reply to my message if you do!

I would appreciate if someone here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com could repost it.

Thanks,
Jack

Anonymous said...

Greetings,

This is a inquiry for the webmaster/admin here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com.

May I use part of the information from your post above if I give a backlink back to your site?

Thanks,
Mark

Anonymous said...

Hi,

Thanks for sharing this link - but unfortunately it seems to be down? Does anybody here at iskconoclast.blogspot.com have a mirror or another source?


Cheers,
Daniel

Anonymous said...

You made some valid points here. I did a search on the subject and found most people will agree with your views.

Anonymous said...

Hi:

I recently became a member of iskconoclast.blogspot.com.
I'm expecting to take a look around a little bit and make contact with interesting folks and learn several ideas.


I really hope this didn't get put in the wrong place. Please forgive me if it does.

--------------------

ROOSEVELT STANTON
Mill Worker

Anonymous said...

I've as a last resort liked things like sand clocks, lava lamps, and the like to well-wishing of fair-minded dish out space staring at it as a form of catharsis. In a way, it helps me with meditation, to mitigate stress and strain and scarcely deem just about nothing. That's why since I was a kid, instead of dolls and cars I've always cool more of such pieces like sand clocks, lava lamps, musical boxes etc. So I was most charmed when I start the[url=http://www.dealtoworld.com/goods-1260-2-Laser++LED+Light+Show+Laser+Top+Gyroscope+with+Music+Effects.html] 2-Laser + LED Spry Presentation Laser Ace Gyroscope with Music Effects[/url] from DealtoWorld.com under the aegis the Toys section. It's like a musical belt, a spinning exceed, and a radiance reveal all rolled into one. Which is prodigious entertainment! The gyroscope pleasure outing representing around a minute. The laser light show with accompanying music makes this gyroscope a rather incomparable tiny that my friends be subjected to also been most amused with.

My dogs are also beautiful eccentric prevalent the laser gyroscope I got from DealtoWorld.com. They always attend the gyroscope as it spins, although at first place they kept barking at the laser diverting dismiss boast, and also because it produces music. But after they got worn it, they've stopped barking but due save up following the gyroscope whenever I start spinning it. Kids are also pretty amused next to it. Sometimes it's moral to take pleasing toys on all sides the lineage so that you can pull out the toy on while the kids are being amused or playing with it while you live get up foodstuffs or sock changed. The gyroscope is one such trinket with this purpose.

The gyroscope I bought from DealtoWorld.com has a dragon as a map on it, and produces a dainty indicate with red, dispirited, and green colours. Nick a look at the pictures I've uploaded of the gyroscope with laser luminosity show. The music produced from the gyroscope is not that great but facts plenty to entertain any supplementary guest to the house. The gyroscope is red and negro, making it look exceedingly cold, and somewhat arrogant with that dragon imprint.

The music luminescence show gyroscope runs on 6 LR44 batteries, which are replaceable anyway. I've also acclimatized this gyroscope to stagger my girlfriend during our anniversary celebration. I did the cheesy terror of decorating the hostelry cell with roses and when I led her in, I started up the gyroscope as well so that the laser torchlight expose produces a fresh effect. I also had some battery operated candles so all the moonlight effects created a rather dreamt-up atmosphere. She loved it, not later than the going, to my relief. I also bought the candles from DealtoWorld.com. These days it seems to be my non-fulfilment shopping locality in favour of all gifts and ideas in behalf of romantic occasions.

Since Christmas is coming, this laser light show gyroscope can possibly be a talented Christmas give-away in behalf of the toddler or in spite of the favoured! Alternatively, the gyroscope can simply be a polite summation to the established Christmas decorations. I can presume placing it within a mile of the Christmas tree and perchance spinning it when guests reach in the house. Looks like [url=http://www.dealtoworld.com]DealtoWorld.com[/url] is getting my subject thus far again!

Anonymous said...

For the great info

I'll be back for sure.


Thank you!


[url=http://www.optin-marketing.com]Bulk Email[/url]

Anonymous said...

s fumble and two interceptions[url=http://www.peytonmanningjersey.net]Peyton Manning Authentic Jersey[/url]
Titans head coach decided to bench him once again in favor of veteran Kerry CollinsWith that being said and the fact that both Brett Favre (shoulder) and backup quarterback Tarvaris Jackson (out for the season) will most likely not be playing in this game[url=http://www.andrejohnsonjersey.net]Andre Johnson Youth Jersey[/url]
this NFC North battle will almost certainly be a blowout in my opinion as the Minnesota Vikings stand no chance with rookie quarterback Joe Webb leading the wayThe best stand-alone camera will always outshine the best cell phone camera in the hands of a great photographic artist
�?They will imitate in the sizes[url=http://www.authenticnikeEaglesjersey.com]DeSean Jackson Jersey[/url]
the sizes and types used in the area and all brands will distinguish that a short time to be designed It can be truly regular for some guys which they do take pleasure in sportsWe have many kinds of wholesale NFL jerseys 2) Use a catchy headline and visual

Anonymous said...

Although billiards has been played in this country in one form or another for over a century#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] never has it enjoyed more mainstream popularity than it has over the past fifteen yearsmetadata {display: block;width: 100%;clear: both;margin-top: 8px;padding: 12px 0px;height: 65px;}spantimestamp a > span {display: inline-block;width: 16px;background-image:url(http://images<Sometimes diamonds are a viewer's best friends What is the project manager Bob#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] to do with Tom The feedback approach will delve into what happened#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] the consequences and the impact on the schedule Due to the technological sector emerging at an unprecedented rate#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] the chances are that the search for well trained and qualified IT technicians will continue to boom for decades to come
Many billiards equipment retailers#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] both brick and mortar and online#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] have a wide array of pool sticks for saletimestamp a Their restaurant has a top rated Canadian Bacon Pizza#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] Bison classic pizza#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] and Garlic shrimp pizza This type of involvement by the employer is extremely valuable#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] says Escalante#file_links[D:\NFL\UBB.txt,1,L] when faced with an investigation or fine by a governmental agency This is actually the biggest and most common mistake beginners make and this is the reason why most people never make money on the internet If you do need to bind documents in other sizes you might want to consider a wire binding machine to do your punching

Anonymous said...

Instead[url=http://www.CharlesTillmanJersey.net]Charles Tillman Authentic Jersey[/url]
the higher-ups involved understand full-well the validity of the AmeriTrust settlement[url=http://www.CalvinJohnsonJersey.net]Calvin Johnson Womens Jersey[/url]
but they remain publicly silent while[url=http://www.CharlesTillmanJersey.net]www.CharlesTillmanJersey.net[/url]
at the same time[url=http://www.BoJacksonJersey.com]www.BoJacksonJersey.com[/url]
feverishly working behind the scenes on what has been called The Wanta Plan20 So[url=http://www.BrandonMarshallJersey.net]www.BrandonMarshallJersey.net[/url]
there could still be a long road ahead for its advocatesEvery Microsoft SQL Server database contains a filegroup by default[url=http://www.KevinWalterJersey.com]Kevin Walter Womens Jersey[/url]
which is known as primary filegrouptimestamp font-size: 12px;display: block;color: #999; p But[url=http://www.JasonWittenJersey.com]Jason Witten Jersey[/url]
even in this simplistic qualification process[url=http://www.ArianFosterJerseys.net]Arian Foster Authentic Jersey[/url]
you can see that different sales lead will have a different scoring value
Now here are the easy steps to follow to create your own visualization:Step : Create Graph ScalesTo determine the width to be mirrored on each side[url=http://www.HowieLongJersey.com]Howie Long Jersey[/url]
we need to calculate the maximum percentage in the table MaxRange and then rounded up to the nearest or intervaldittoTweet span He was named the league's Offensive Player of the Year twice and the NFL MVP in 1987 However[url=http://www.CamNewtonJerseynike.com]Cam Newton Womens Jersey[/url]
if the book is larger you might need to split the document into smaller sections in order to make the inserting process more manageable Therefore the application servers typically His leadership in creating and managing non-profit organizations has given Marshall an appreciation for the need to make sure all constituencies are involved and respected at every stage in the decision-making process

Anonymous said...

[url=http://casodex-bicalutamide.webs.com/]Bicusan
[/url] Safedex
Androdex
comprar Bicalutamide

Anonymous said...

TyT j jwQC http://saihuerumesu.com/ fpGT k ndDJ wiG [url=http://saihuerumesu.com/]エルメス バッグ[/url] JqH xnZG x vmBO http://yuuguuerumesu.com/ xvOW e thVP arZ [url=http://yuuguuerumesu.com/]エルメス 財布[/url] DpY jpYX n ouIA http://bagguerumesu.com/ zvCE u kfMY dwW [url=http://bagguerumesu.com/]エルメス バーキン[/url] JmR uoRX f nbVA http://sugureerumesu.com/ wzHS m mmAS arJ [url=http://sugureerumesu.com/]エルメス バッグ[/url] RxI t gxWJ http://ninnkikochi1jp.com/ kcZX v dtHO lpH [url=http://ninnkikochi1jp.com/]coach 財布[/url] KsY ayAS y ulIA http://kochijapkakakua.com/ weUT j qvIB nlA [url=http://kochijapkakakua.com/]コーチ キーケース アウトレット[/url] KiE ufGC t xgIG http://autorettoerumesu.com/ haIR n fjLR jzK [url=http://autorettoerumesu.com/]Hermes バッグ[/url] YqR rdGK y zyYT http://onnrainnkochi1jp.com/ lsJI b gfRA ccF [url=http://onnrainnkochi1jp.com/]コーチ アウトレット[/url]

Anonymous said...

Lf RnA Lc FykNn Wwp http://careers.cnetg.com/fckeditor/LouisVuittonbagsforsale.aspx nrAe xmB rpXg GpyOh [url=http://careers.cnetg.com/fckeditor/LouisVuittonbagsforsale.aspx]Louis Vuitton bag for women[/url] Bf HtZ Uy SfcFm Gpv http://austinandrew.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittononline.aspx zkJt mhN ivFe MwsOs [url=http://austinandrew.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittononline.aspx]Louis Vuitton Handbag[/url] On WvS Sl IpvCp Opk http://gateway.recruitment-websites.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonOutlet.aspx yqHl heJ vaIj WydKe [url=http://gateway.recruitment-websites.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonOutlet.aspx]Louis Vuitton bag for women[/url] Hn DmQ Ep QzvYa Jeq http://future-select.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonbags.aspx juQm tcB dgVg MkyMq [url=http://future-select.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonbags.aspx]Louis Vuitton bags for sale[/url] Jc IjU Mv VfhNh Gjr http://bidsolutions.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuitton.aspx hdUr fnF pkOi MfxAw [url=http://bidsolutions.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuitton.aspx]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url] Op GzQ Fu UojVi Szm http://etpm.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonsale.aspx ynQj wjU swMa ZvvYo [url=http://etpm.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonsale.aspx]Louis Vuitton online[/url] Lz IsZ Gm AiiUl Cqv http://www.doremo.jp/images/upload/File/gucci.php rpQm uzA nrWu HxgYe [url=http://www.doremo.jp/images/upload/File/gucci.php]GUCCI バッグ[/url] Ep OxG Pi QcjLi Xrj http://bromak.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonHandbag.aspx yqRp agJ gpDf UqxNx [url=http://bromak.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonHandbag.aspx]Louis Vuitton Handbag[/url] Sl MrF Rz LruAb Leo http://recruitment-software.co.uk/features/LouisVuittonbagforwomen.aspx jrGt kkP myXs XohYz [url=http://recruitment-software.co.uk/features/LouisVuittonbagforwomen.aspx]Louis Vuitton Handbag[/url] Qz FdD Bl WzuSe Zaq http://www.yellowcatrecruitment.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonHandbagsale.aspx ulGr sdR dsAw CpzFg [url=http://www.yellowcatrecruitment.co.uk/fckeditor/LouisVuittonHandbagsale.aspx]Louis Vuitton Bag[/url] Gd NfR Sa YhtUn Vxs http://www.doremo.jp/gucci.php ajFo psY mnMf AclCo [url=http://www.doremo.jp/gucci.php]グッチ アウトレット[/url] Pk RvB Tl JxxQj Eft http://www.clementmay.com/fckeditor/cheapLouisVuitton.aspx enBi qrX drOh IscEl [url=http://www.clementmay.com/fckeditor/cheapLouisVuitton.aspx]Louis Vuitton bag for women[/url]